village voice
Grey Dog's Coming, but Still no Dogs Allowed «
 5:51 pm
Kanye West Premiers the "Stronger" Video «
 3:20 pm
Can Little Kids Be Gay? «
 12:50 pm
Sex Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi
In Defense of Wankers
Sex The Motormouth of the South
In Defense of Wankers
Sex Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi
In Defense of Wankers
Sex Dear Abbey
In Defense of Wankers
Sex Another Brave New World
In Defense of Wankers
Sex Live: The White Stripes at I
In Defense of Wankers
Sex Live: Big Business, Panthers
In Defense of Wankers
Sex Tonight: Cheeseburger, Oxfor
In Defense of Wankers
Tonight: Cheeseburger, Oxford Collapse, Best Fwends
Tonight: Cheeseburger, O
by John E. Coli Nikolai Live: Big Business, Panthers at the Knitting Factory, 06.20.07
Live: Big Business, Pant
by John E. Coli Nikolai
Tonight: Cheeseburger, Oxfor

posted: 12:13 AM, June 21, 2007 by Camille Dodero dude who once founded Citizens Against Car Alarms (an offshoot of Mothers Against Noise?) doesn't sound like t. . .
Live: Big Business, Panthers

Big Business + Panthers Knitting Factory June 19 by Zach Baron Therell be pictures of this somewhere, but so what: Imagine a man, mid six-feet, early thirties, . . .
Live: The White Stripes at I

posted: 2:09 PM, June 20, 2007 by Camille Dodero Photo credited to gaelenh The White Stripes June 19 The Fillmore at Irving Plaza, or something By Rob Harvilla . . .
Another Brave New World

Glenn Mercer's solo debut could be a Feelies reunion. He's just too nice to make it one. by Rob Trucks June 12th, 2007 4:59 PM Though we may be the lone strange. . .
Dear Abbey

The magnificent Abbey Lincoln tackles the most vital songbook yet: her own by Francis Davis June 19th, 2007 3:08 PM Amid more than 20,000 Chicagoans at a free o. . .
Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi

One emcee's quest to sound more like Regina Spektor by Ben Westhoff June 19th, 2007 3:45 PM Indie rap has been good to Louis Logic, a Fat Beatssigned veteran wh. . .
The Motormouth of the South

The platinum Terror Squad medallion worn by Palestinian-American producer and radio announcer DJ Khaled makes quite a thud as it lands on his desk. It's got to . . .
Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi

One emcee's quest to sound more like Regina Spektor by Ben Westhoff June 19th, 2007 3:45 PM Indie rap has been good to Louis Logic, a Fat Beatssigned veteran wh. . .
News
Fell Out of Love With a Band
Dear Abbey
Dear Abbey
Live: Big Business, Panthers at the Knitting Factory, 06.20.07
Live: Big Business, Panthers at the Knitting Factory, 06.20.07

135,000 square feet of prime real estate, empty
photo: Clayton Patterson
be social
Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
The Motormouth of the South

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Dear Abbey

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Another Brave New World

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Live: The White Stripes at I

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Live: Big Business, Panthers

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Tonight: Cheeseburger, Oxfor

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Tonight: Cheeseburger, Oxfor

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Live: Big Business, Panthers

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Live: The White Stripes at I

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Guns Gone Wild

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Suspects as Usual

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Mopping Up

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Revolt from Above

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Pizza Shut

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Long Sentences, Short Storie

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
'Ayo, shorty!'

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Shots in the Dark

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Runnin' Scared: New York's B

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Daddy's Dog

Runnin' Scared by Mara Altman
Absurd bagpipes and half-assed prog retreads sink the Stripes' sixth manifesto
by Nate Cavalieri
June 20th, 2007 12:06 PM
While absorbing the Blueshammer ersatz and pheromone-scented metallurgy of Icky Thump, the White Stripes' sixth record, it's hard not to long for the candy-striped sibs who once sat in that little room, working on something good. Remember them? Way back before the supermodel weddings, Nashville mansions, and sundry side projects? Just Jack on guitar and Meg on drums. So what if she played like a paste-addled fourth-grader? All that stuff about falling in love with a girl, going to Wichita, and seeing rats on the doorstep was as straightforward and vibrant as the wardrobe. Jack himself certainly remembers—on Thump's "Little Cream Soda," he lays aside the thrasher riffs for a second to recall the days when "a wooden box and an alley full of rocks was all I had to care about," only to toss off the sentiment with a dismissive snarl: "Oh well."

"Oh well"? Oh well, the affecting style that made them the most imaginative revivalists of their generation has been replaced by half-assed and half-hearted prog rock. Oh well, the pair of blues tunes here ("300 M.P.H. Torrential Outpour Blues" and "Catch Hell Blues") have such an awkward gait they actually feel like they're played by obligated divorcees. Oh well, it sounds like Jack wrote these songs in five minutes and Meg learned them in three. Oh well, the mere fact of being the White Stripes has spoiled the very thing that once made them saviors.

But unless they're saving the army of Candy Children from a deficiency of Bad Company, tunes like "You Don't Know What Love Is (You Just Do What You're Told)" and "Effect & Cause" don't reinvent the wheel so much as hastily retread it. Owing much to young Ozzy ("Icky Thump"), old Ozzy ("Little Cream Soda"), and Humble Pie ("I'm Slowly Turning Into You"), the rest of Thump 's character seems just as lazily borrowed. What's worse, the scraps of originality—the bullfighting, trumpet-backed fanfare of "Conquest" and the two-part bagpipe jig "Prickly Thorn, but Sweetly Worn/St. Andrew (The Battle Is in the Air)"—are simply absurd.

Which leaves "Rag and Bone," a half-song/half-skit wherein Meg and Jack talk about ransacking a vast, cluttered room in a sprawling mansion. Jack admits the motive ("Make some money out of 'em, at least!"); "This fits me perfect," Meg answers in a greedy whisper. They don't notice that they're still standing in the same little room they once built, but it's just become too icky to recognize. Oh well.

More by Sarah Ferguson
Tonight: Cheeseburger, Oxfor
posted: 12:13 AM, June 21, 2007 by Camille Dodero dude who once founded Citizens Against Car Alarms (an offshoot of Mothers Against Noise?) doesn't sound like t

Live: Big Business, Panthers
Big Business + Panthers Knitting Factory June 19 by Zach Baron Therell be pictures of this somewhere, but so what: Imagine a man, mid six-feet, early thirties,

Live: The White Stripes at I
posted: 2:09 PM, June 20, 2007 by Camille Dodero Photo credited to gaelenh The White Stripes June 19 The Fillmore at Irving Plaza, or something By Rob Harvilla

Another Brave New World
Glenn Mercer's solo debut could be a Feelies reunion. He's just too nice to make it one. by Rob Trucks June 12th, 2007 4:59 PM Though we may be the lone strange

Dear Abbey
The magnificent Abbey Lincoln tackles the most vital songbook yet: her own by Francis Davis June 19th, 2007 3:08 PM Amid more than 20,000 Chicagoans at a free o

Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi
One emcee's quest to sound more like Regina Spektor by Ben Westhoff June 19th, 2007 3:45 PM Indie rap has been good to Louis Logic, a Fat Beatssigned veteran wh

The Motormouth of the South
The platinum Terror Squad medallion worn by Palestinian-American producer and radio announcer DJ Khaled makes quite a thud as it lands on his desk. It's got to

Rap Us a Song, You're the Pi
One emcee's quest to sound more like Regina Spektor by Ben Westhoff June 19th, 2007 3:45 PM Indie rap has been good to Louis Logic, a Fat Beatssigned veteran wh

Places & Spaces
Hip Neighborhoods, Unique Properties, Innovative Designs

» click here to see more...

OBIE Supplement
Celebrate Off and Off - Off Broadway Theater

» click here to see more...

Summer Guide
Village Voice 2007 Summer "Local Warming"

» click here to see more...

Education Supplement
Spring 2007 - Life Lessons

» click here to see more...

Spring Arts Guide
Village Voice 2007 Spring Guide for Arts & Entertainment

» click here to see more...